Home / Blog

How customers choose between two shops on Google

Last updated 22 October 2026 · By Autonova Solutions, Mumbai

It is 9pm. Your car is making a strange noise, and tomorrow is Sunday. You type “car service near me” and two garages in Thane appear side by side. You look at both for a few seconds, then you call one.

What decided it? Often a handful of small things on the Google page. This post turns them into a checklist, so an owner can see the page the way that customer does.

What does a customer check before calling a shop?

A customer compares the stars, the number of reviews, how recent the reviews are, whether the owner replies, whether the page was updated lately, the photos and the opening hours. The whole check happens in a few seconds, on a phone.

1. Stars. The rating is the first thing the eye lands on. A very high score with only a handful of reviews may feel thin. Google’s help page says, “A mix of positive and negative feedback often feels more trustworthy.”
2. Number of reviews. More reviews feel like more people have tried the shop. 230 reviews may feel safer than 12, even at the same rating.
3. How recent the reviews are. A review from two days ago says the shop is busy now. A newest review from last year makes a customer ask what changed.
4. Replies. If the owner answers, the customer sees someone who listens. If every review sits alone, the customer may guess that a call will go the same way. Our post on why Google reviews matter covers this too.
5. A recent update. A fresh post, even a small one, says the business is awake. A page quiet for months can look forgotten.
6. Photos. Real, recent photos help a customer picture the visit. A few old ones do the opposite.
7. Opening hours. At 9pm the customer wants to know one thing: can I come tomorrow? Missing hours mean one more thing to find out, so some customers may just call the next shop.

Shop A vs Shop B: who gets the call?

Look at two example garages in Thane. City Car Care has slightly higher stars and more reviews. Sharma Auto Works answers every review, updates its page and shows its hours. A customer may call Sharma Auto Works first, even though the stars are a little lower.

Why might a customer call the garage with fewer stars?

Because stars are only one signal on the page. Shop B leads by 0.1 stars and 18 reviews, but Shop A looks active, answers people and shows its hours. A customer may read that as a garage that will pick up the phone. It is a possibility, not a rule.

The stars differ by 0.1, which a customer may not even notice. Two days against three weeks, 20 replies against 2, and missing hours are easier to notice. Shop B may still win some calls, since every customer weighs things differently.

Which of these can you fix today?

Some items on the checklist are yours to change. Some are not.

What you control

• Replies. You can answer every review, starting with the oldest. Google’s local ranking tips say, “Positive reviews and helpful replies can help your business stand out.”
• Updates. You can post something small each month, such as a pre-monsoon service reminder.
• Photos. You can add a few real ones.
• Hours. You can add them in five minutes.

What you do not control

• The exact stars. They come from real customers. Do not buy or swap reviews, as Google prohibits it.
• Distance. Google’s local ranking page says, “Distance refers to how far each business is from the customer who’s searching.” You cannot move the garage.

A complete profile matters too, as we explain in does Google Business Profile help local SEO, and there is more on standing out in how to get ahead of the shop next door.

If replies and monthly updates are the part you never get to, ReviewSaathi writes them. It writes one post a month, which you approve first. See the homepage for current status.

Add my Google page (5 minutes)